Trending
At some point, Warren needs to stop confusing the preservation of an old building with economic development. The endless debate over 231-237 Pennsylvania Avenue West is a perfect example.
This property has sat vacant for years. The city’s redevelopment documents indicate that the building lacks water, electricity and heat, and requires roof repairs or replacement. Demolition specifications also call for asbestos abatement. Walk past the glass door, and you can still see the outline of a former state representative’s office decal. That faded reminder says plenty about how long this property has gone unused.
I appreciate the residents who have shown up to advocate for preservation. Their passion deserves respect. But let’s keep the numbers in perspective. The initial meeting room had a capacity of 24, and reports indicate that dozens attended.
That’s meaningful participation, but it is not a survey of Warren’s 9,046 residents. Remember how contentious the downtown roundabout became? City Council even voted 5-2 to ask PennDOT to change course. Meeting attendance alone cannot tell us what the entire community wants.
More importantly, what is the realistic financial plan?
The Warren Heritage Community Alliance’s own marketplace proposal projects $2.5 million in renovation costs and operating deficits in each of its first 10 years. Its projected loss is $127,872 in Year 1 and still approximately $86,300 in Year 10. Those are forecasts, not actual losses, but they deserve scrutiny. Proposed grants and donations are not the same as secured funding.
I support demolishing the building, with proper asbestos handling and environmental safeguards, and giving this valuable downtown site a fresh start. But demolition by itself is not redevelopment.
The city’s Nov. 4 Right-to-Know response says the Redevelopment Authority had not drafted or approved a plan to market or redevelop the property after demolition. That’s a problem that needs fixing now, not after the rubble is hauled away.
Set deadlines. Seek serious proposals. Prioritize housing, businesses and private investment. Tell residents what success will look like and who is accountable for delivering it.
Warren cannot preserve its way out of decline, and it cannot demolish its way into prosperity without a plan. We can respect the past without leaving another vacant property for the next generation.
Warren needs progress, not another decade of promises.
Robert J. Marrone is a Warren resident.